Skip to main content
Altivus

Cybersecurity

Feeling Secure Isn’t the Same as Being Secure: What 1,000 Small Business Leaders Told the National Cybersecurity Alliance

By Kyle Maulden · October 12, 2026

Business owner at a desk at dusk reviewing cybersecurity, padlock in window

Article Summary: The National Cybersecurity Alliance’s 2026 survey of 1,000 small and midsize business leaders, run in partnership with CISA, found that most feel confident about their cybersecurity, yet more than half can’t confirm they made it through the past year without an incident. The survey points to tools that were bought but not fully switched on, tested, or put under a written policy. Here are four questions worth asking before you assume you’re covered.

Every October, Cybersecurity Awareness Month brings a wave of new reports. Most of them say some version of “threats are rising.” This year’s 2026 Small Business Cybersecurity Awareness & Practices Survey, published by the National Cybersecurity Alliance in partnership with CISA, says something more useful: the biggest risk for many small businesses may be how confident they feel.

The confidence gap, in numbers

The survey asked 1,000 SMB decision-makers across 10 industries how they see their own risk. A few findings stand out:

  • 86.3% said they have medium to very high confidence in their ability to manage cyber risk.
  • 72.3% said their risk has increased or stayed the same over the past year.
  • 56.1% could not confirm a clean security record for the last 12 months. That includes 50.5% who had a confirmed or suspected incident and 5.6% who simply didn’t know.

That last number deserves a second read. Roughly one in eighteen business leaders couldn’t say whether they’d been breached. If something went wrong, nobody would necessarily have noticed.

Confidence isn’t a bad thing. But confidence that hasn’t been checked tends to rest on a simple assumption: “We bought the right things, so we’re protected.” The survey’s numbers suggest that assumption deserves checking.

Having a tool isn’t the same as using it

The report’s most practical finding is the gap between having a security control and fully using it.

Multi-factor authentication (MFA). MFA is the extra step, like a code on your phone, that stops someone who has stolen a password. 86.8% of businesses have it, but only 51.1% require it on all key business accounts. Attackers don’t need every account. They need the one that was skipped, often an old admin login, a shared mailbox, or the accounting system “we’ll get to later.”

Backups. 88.4% of businesses have backups, but only 61.4% have actually tested them. A backup nobody has restored from is a hope, not a plan. Ransomware is a bad time to learn that the backup stopped running months ago or doesn’t include the files you need.

AI tools. 87.3% of businesses now use AI tools, but only 45.6% have formal guidelines for how employees use them. Without a policy, people make their own calls about what customer data, contracts, or financials are fine to paste into a chatbot.

The survey doesn’t say why these gaps exist, but the pattern is consistent: the tool is in place and the follow-through isn’t.

Breached businesses report better habits

Here’s the uncomfortable pattern in the data: businesses that have already been breached report noticeably better habits than those that haven’t.

  • 74.9% of breached organizations have a documented, followed incident response plan, compared with 51.5% of those that haven’t been breached.
  • Businesses that haven’t had a breach are five times more likely to have no response plan at all (30.3% vs. 5.9%).
  • Tested backups follow the same pattern: 70.3% among breached organizations versus 53.8% among the rest.

The survey doesn’t show which came first. One plausible reading is that some companies tighten things up only after a painful lesson. The goal is to get the benefit of that lesson without paying for it.

Four small business cybersecurity questions to ask this month

You don’t need a security team to start closing the gap. You need honest answers to a few questions, ideally in writing.

  1. Is MFA required on every account that matters? Not “turned on for most people,” but required on email, banking, payroll, accounting, cloud file storage, and remote access, including admin and shared accounts.
  2. When did we last restore something from backup? Pick a real file or system and bring it back. Then put the next test on the calendar for next quarter.
  3. Do we have a one-page AI policy? List which tools are approved, what kinds of data should never go into them, and who to ask when someone’s unsure. A short, clear page beats a long document nobody reads.
  4. Does everyone know what to do in the first hour of a problem? Who gets called, by phone, and what shouldn’t be touched? If that plan lives only in one person’s head, it isn’t a plan yet. Our guide on what to do in the first hour of a cyberattack is a good starting point.

If you carry cyber insurance, these questions matter twice. Carriers increasingly check whether your controls were actually in place on the day of an incident, not just whether you checked a box on the application. We covered that in more detail in Your Cyber Insurance Application Is a Promise.

The bottom line

The businesses in this survey aren’t careless. They made reasonable investments and reasonably assumed those investments were working. The difference between feeling secure and being secure is usually a handful of unglamorous follow-through tasks: enforcing what you already own, testing what you already pay for, and writing down what everyone already half-knows.

Cybersecurity Awareness Month is a good excuse to check. If you’d like a second set of eyes on where your gaps might be, the Altivus team is happy to walk through these four questions with you, wherever your business is located.

Filed under Cybersecurity

A practical next step

Ready to discuss your situation?

Bring the question you are trying to answer. We can start with the business need and clarify the appropriate next step.

Office address
151 FM-407
Suite 200
Argyle, TX 76226

Fields marked are required.

What can we help with?

A short business explanation is enough. Please don’t include passwords or confidential records.

We use these details to respond to you. See our Privacy Policy.