Skip to main content
Altivus

Managed IT & Strategy

What Does Internal IT Really Cost vs. Outsourced IT?

By Lorenzo Martinez · July 29, 2026

Article Summary: This is a practical look at internal IT vs outsourced IT costs for SMBs, factoring in salary, tooling, and security — not just headcount. Internal IT can run $175K–$470K+ annually once fully equipped, and carries added risk from single points of failure and burnout. MSPs offer broader coverage and expertise, often at comparable or lower cost, while co-managed IT provides a middle ground for businesses wanting to keep trusted staff while closing gaps. The takeaway: compare total cost and risk, not just salary versus monthly fee.

For many small and medium-sized businesses, IT eventually reaches a crossroads. The company has grown past “call someone when something breaks,” but it may not be ready, or willing, to build a full internal IT department.

Should we hire one or two onsite IT employees, or should we partner with a Managed Service Provider?

The answer depends on your business, your risk tolerance, your compliance needs, and your growth plans. But once you look beyond salary as the only dollar figure to compare and factor in tools, security, coverage, burnout, and institutional knowledge, a more “apples-to-apples” comparison can be done.

The Real Cost of Hiring One or Two Internal IT Employees

Hiring internal IT can feel like the most direct solution. You get someone onsite, embedded in the business, familiar with the people, systems, quirks, and priorities. That has real value. But the cost is rarely just the employee’s salary.

For example, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median annual wage for network and computer systems administrators was $96,800 in May 2024.

For budgeting purposes, many SMBs should expect one experienced IT technician between $80,000 to $120,000 salary, one Senior IT/Security-focused hire between $110,000 to $150,000 salary, and a two-person internal IT team between $170,000 to $270,000+ in combined salary.

Small-business payroll guidance commonly estimates that total employee cost can run 25% to 40% above base salary.

As a result, a single $100,000 IT employee may realistically cost closer to $125,000 to $140,000 per year. A two-person team could easily land between $220,000 and $375,000+ per year before accounting for the IT tools they need to operate effectively.

The Hidden Cost: Building the IT Tech Stack

A modern IT department needs more than a knowledgeable employee. It needs operational and security tooling that meets a defined standard. Without it, your internal hire may be stuck manually checking systems, reacting to tickets without proper tracking, and trying to secure the business with limited visibility.

For a 50-person business, a practical internal IT tool stack might look like this:

Tool CategoryEstimated Monthly Cost
PSA / ticketing$100 to $300
RMM / patching / remote support$200 to $500
EDR or endpoint security$250 to $700
MDR or SOC monitoring$500 to $2,500+
Password manager$150 to $350
MFA / identity security$150 to $500
Secure DNS filtering$50 to $250
Email security$150 to $600
Backup / SaaS backup$250 to $1,000+
Documentation / asset management$100 to $400
SIEM / log management$500 to $2,000+
Security awareness training$100 to $300

A very lean tool stack may cost $1,500 to $3,000 per month.

A more security-conscious stack can easily reach $4,000 to $8,000+ per month, or $48,000 to $96,000+ per year, especially when MDR, SIEM, backup, and compliance tools are included.

This brings the total cost of one internal IT employee plus tooling may be closer to $175,000 to $240,000+ per year. For two employees plus tooling the total cost is between $270,000 to $470,000+ per year.

The Operational Risk of a Small Internal IT Team

Cost is only part of the equation. Risk matters just as much.

A single onsite IT person can become a single point of failure. If they are sick, on vacation, unavailable, overloaded, or eventually leave the company, the business may lose access to critical knowledge.

Even with detailed documentation, one person cannot know everything. IT has become too broad. A modern SMB may need knowledge across Microsoft 365, Azure, networking, cybersecurity, compliance, backups, endpoints, mobile devices, user training, vendor management, and business continuity.

That is a lot to expect from one person.

However, two internal employees reduce some risk, but they do not eliminate it. They may still be stretched thin, especially if one person specializes in infrastructure and the other focuses on helpdesk. Institutional knowledge can become compartmentalized, where each person knows their own area but not the full environment.

Then there is burnout.

Internal IT teams are often expected to be available whenever something breaks. That can mean after-hours emergencies, weekend maintenance, urgent executive requests, security alerts, and constant interruptions. Over time, this can eliminate work-life balance, increase turnover risk, and reduce the quality of support.

How an MSP Changes the Equation

A Managed Service Provider brings a different model.

Instead of relying on one or two people, an MSP gives the business access to a team. That team may include help desk technicians, systems administrators, network engineers, cloud specialists, cybersecurity analysts, project engineers, and strategic consultants.

MSP pricing varies by region, scope, and security maturity, but published 2025 and 2026 pricing guides commonly place managed IT services around $100 to $250 per user per month, with more advanced security or consulting-focused packages sometimes reaching higher.

For a 50-user business, that may translate to:

  • Basic managed IT: $5,000 to $8,000 per month
  • Standard managed IT with stronger security: $7,500 to $12,500 per month
  • Advanced managed IT with MDR, compliance, and strategic planning: $12,500 to $18,000+ per month

At first glance, that may sound comparable to hiring internal staff. But the difference is what a mature MSP actually includes — a full IT tool stack and more.

Better Coverage, Less Burnout, and Broader Expertise

One of the biggest benefits of an MSP is coverage.

A single employee can only work so many hours. An MSP, however, can distribute work across multiple technicians and shifts. When coverage is shared no single person carries every emergency, after-hours support can be rotated or formally staffed, escalations go to subject matter experts, vacation does not create a coverage crisis.

This is not just better for IT workers, it is better for the business. Support becomes more consistent, documentation improves, and the company benefits from lessons learned across many client environments.

An MSP also sees patterns that a single internal hire may not. Because MSPs support multiple businesses, they often encounter a wider range of issues, tools, vendors, attacks, migrations, and compliance scenarios. That broader exposure can lead to faster diagnosing, problem-solving, and relevant recommendations.

The Best of Both Worlds: Co-Managed IT

The best answer is not always in-house or MSP. Sometimes, the strongest model is both.

Co-managed IT allows a business to keep its internal IT employee while using an MSP to augment their capabilities. This can be useful when the onsite person is trusted, knowledgeable, and culturally aligned with the company, but overwhelmed by the growing complexity of the environment.

In this model, the internal IT person remains the face of IT for the business, while the MSP provides backup, tools, escalation support, and specialized expertise.

This frees the onsite IT employee to focus on higher-value work, internal relationships, process improvement, business applications, and strategic projects.

It also gives that employee someone to call. With a co-managed MSP relationship, the onsite person gains access to a bench of peers, specialists, and escalation resources. Instead of being expected to solve every issue alone, they become part of a larger support ecosystem.

For businesses that do not want to replace their IT employee, co-managed IT can be the ideal path. It protects the company while supporting the employee.

Comparing the Models

ModelStrengthsRisks
One onsite IT employeeDeep familiarity, onsite presence, fast informal supportSingle point of failure, limited skill coverage, burnout, vacation gaps
Two onsite IT employeesBetter coverage, more shared knowledge, some specializationHigher cost, still limited depth, possible knowledge silos
MSPBroader team, better tooling, scalable coverage, security maturityLess physically embedded, quality varies by provider
Co-managed ITKeeps internal knowledge while adding MSP scale and expertiseRequires clear roles, communication, and process alignment

So Which Option Is Right?

If your business values having someone embedded every day, internal IT may make sense.

Businesses that need broader coverage, stronger cybersecurity, better documentation, structured processes, and predictable scaling may get more value from an MSP at a lower or comparable cost.

And if you already have an internal IT employee you trust, but they are stretched thin, co-managed IT may be the smartest move.

The key is to avoid comparing only salary versus monthly MSP fee. A realistic comparison should include the total costs including the IT tech stack.

When all those factors are considered, many SMBs find that an MSP provides either lower total cost, better coverage, or both.

Final Thought

Technology is now too important to manage casually. For small and medium-sized businesses, IT is not just about fixing computers. It is about protecting revenue, securing data, enabling employees, supporting growth, and reducing risk.

If you are unsure whether your current IT model is costing too much, creating too much risk, or placing too much pressure on one person, now is the right time to review it.

Schedule an IT audit today to compare your current internal costs, tool stack, security posture against industry best practices, and support coverage against a managed or co-managed IT model. The right partner can help you reduce risk, improve service, and give your team the support they need to grow with confidence.

Filed under Managed IT & Strategy

A practical next step

Ready to discuss your situation?

Bring the question you are trying to answer. We can start with the business need and clarify the appropriate next step.

Office address
151 FM-407
Suite 200
Argyle, TX 76226

Fields marked are required.

What can we help with?

A short business explanation is enough. Please don’t include passwords or confidential records.

We use these details to respond to you. See our Privacy Policy.